Google has presented school districts with what many consider a "ultimatum": either allow students to see AI summaries in Google searches, or simply abandon the Google Search on their school accounts.
In August, Google enabled the Gemini tab page by default for students at K-12, provided that the schools had previously allowed the use of their AI chatbot Gemini. On November 3rd, Google changed its policy, announcing that starting from the beginning of next year, the AI tool would not be enabled on students' accounts at K-12 unless school administrators actively enabled it. However, Google also made it clear that schools wishing to allow students to continue using Google Search must accept AI Overviews – a type of summary generated by AI that has now become common at the top of search results.
Vice President of Google's Education Business, Chris Phillips, told The New York Times: "Search and AI are deeply integrated." He added that students at schools that do not allow AI will "not be able to use search; they will see a message from the school indicating that this feature is not available."
Due to concerns about safety and privacy, many school districts have restricted or prohibited the use of AI by students. Perhaps they did not anticipate that such restrictions would cause students to lose access to one of the world's most popular search engines, and this decision has also led education technology experts to question Google's rationale.
Google's decision comes at a time when tech companies are facing increasing legal pressure, with the focus of controversy being the harm caused to children by their products. In March this year, a jury in Los Angeles ruled that Meta and Google's subsidiary YouTube were negligent for failing to warn users about the dangers on their platforms. In January, Google and its associated chatbot company Character.AI agreed to settle multiple lawsuits brought by families who claimed their children had been harmed by the chatbots.
Earlier this month, a family sued Google, accusing its 13-year-old daughter of using a Gemini provided by the school to plan her suicide, and claiming that Google promoted its AI product to the student without notifying the parents or the school.
A Google spokesperson said, "We have heard the concerns of parents and teachers about students taking shortcuts using AI, and we share the same goal: to help students learn." He also mentioned that the company is piloting a new Gemini feature to support "productive struggle" and help students "solve problems without directly jumping to the answers."
Whether this is sufficient to win the support of school districts that have already restricted AI is another question. The four largest school districts in the United States hold different positions on the issue of AI and Google's binding of AI with Search.
Alphabet is Google's parent company and has not responded to the comment request from Fortune.
Chicago: 'We don't want your Gemini'
The Chicago public school system has seen the strongest backlash. On December 22, 2025, the district began to block students from using ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, and other third-party AI products. Students are only allowed to use AI enhanced educational technology tools that have gone through the district's compliance process and meet the requirements of Illinois Student Data Privacy Law SOPPA.
On November 11th, about 30 protesters gathered outside Google's office in the West Ring area, shouting, "Hey, Google, don't try to fool us. We don't want your Gemini."
A spokesperson for the Chicago public school system stated in a statement to the Chicago Sun-Times that the district “is actively exploring all options to independently block” AI Overviews in searches for Google.
The spokesperson said, "The school district hopes to continue to allow students to use the Google search engine that does not contain the AI component. If such an arrangement cannot be made, the school district will look for other search solutions."
New York City: Chatbots are shut down, but AI Overviews is still active.
The largest school district in the United States, the public school system of New York City, also seems to be moving in a similar direction, although no final decision has yet been made. On September 2nd, Mayor Zohran Mamdani and School Superintendent Kamar Samuels announced a one-year suspension of AI for students from grades 2-K to 8. They also prohibited the use of companion chat robots in all grades.
After Google announced the aforementioned policy, Mamdani posted on X, saying: "Google is attempting to use its monopoly power to force AI into our public schools. No company should have the right to decide how we educate our children."
The Mayor of the City, Julie Menin, and the city council member, Shekar Krishnan, wrote to Google's CEO, Sundar Pichai, asking whether Google would allow students to continue using Google Search without the use of AI Overviews; if not, what would be the reason. The letter mentioned that considering Google's practice of limiting product features for younger users, such as YouTube Kids, this issue is particularly noteworthy. It was also stated in the letter that the school district has approximately 1.3 million Chromebook, of which 500,000 are allocated to students.
A spokesperson for the school district, Nicole Brownstein, told Gothamist that officials "are in contact with Google to further discuss this update," and stated that the school district has already disabled the Gemini chatbot and AI Mode among students. If Google does not compromise, the largest school district in the United States will have to make a choice between relaxing its stance or finding another search engine.
Los Angeles: The entire school district AI has banned access to Google searches
On September 2, the Los Angeles Unified School District, the second-largest school district in the United States, announced that it will block generative AI on district-owned devices for students of all grades during the 2026-27 academic year. This measure is expected to affect approximately 378,000 students.
During a public comment session at a special committee meeting on district-generated AI held after Google announced its policy, parents and Schools Beyond Screens member Hillary Power called on the Los Angeles Unified School District to continue to “formalize, extend, and expand the current suspension order that prohibits students from grades T-K to 12 from using AI.”
She said, "A few days ago, Google issued a monopolistic and, frankly, pathetic ultimatum, demanding that schools use their AI search product, otherwise they would face service disruption."
According to LAist, the school district has requested Google to provide a way to turn off AI summaries and stated that they are reviewing Google's announcement as well as its "potential impact" on schools, educators, and students.
Miami: Google's largest school partner faces new state-level regulations
The public school system in Miami-Dade County, the third-largest school district in the United States, may be heading in a different direction.
According to The New York Times, in 2023, the school district blocked chatbots such as ChatGPT and other similar chatbots due to concerns about cheating and false information. Two years later, the district changed its stance and provided Gemini, for, and Education to approximately 100,000 high school students; at that time, this was the largest deployment of its kind among school districts in the United States. In February, the district announced that it would continue to collaborate with Google to allow all high school students to use full-length SAT mock exams for free, through Gemini.
However, on September 16th, the Florida State Board of Education voted to require public school districts and charter schools to establish rules for the use of AI. Schools must also inform parents and guardians of which AI tools students will have access to, so that families can choose to allow their children to use certain tools or request non-AI alternative solutions. All school districts must comply by July 1, 2027.
Miami-Dade County public school system has not responded to questions regarding how it will adapt to Google's policies and the new regulations in Florida.
This move has sparked even more doubts.
Former Chair of the U.S. Federal Trade Commission, Lina Khan, criticized Google for linking Search and AI summaries together. In a post on X on November 3rd, she stated that Google is using its dominant search position to “coerce schools into adopting AI.”
She said, "Multiple courts have already determined that Google has violated antitrust laws, and this latest move indicates that it has not yet reined in its behavior." She also stated, "As more and more people oppose the use of AI in schools, Google is clearly signaling that it will punish those who do not comply."
It's not just Khan who questions the legality of this practice. Professor Zephyr Teachout from Fotonmofa College stated that she believes Google's claim of being unable to unbind AI Overviews from Search is 'lacking credibility', and that the company may be found in violation of anti-monopoly laws regarding the bundling of two products for sale.
In antitrust law, "bundling sales" refers to a situation where a company with significant market power requires customers who wish to purchase one of its products to also buy another product. Google's parent company, Alphabet, ranked 5th on the 2026 Fortune 500 list of the largest companies in the United States. According to FTC, if bundling practices "limit competition without bringing any benefits to consumers," it can lead to antitrust issues.
Teachout said: "Google has been operating its search engine without AI for decades, and it has filters that allow people to view results without AI summaries. Moreover, its response to the bundled allegations has been inconsistent – claiming that the two are 'deeply integrated' is not a legal argument at all. The company has control over the K-12 administrators and could easily implement the same control for searches and AI as well."
Google has previously lost a case regarding bundled sales. In April 2025, a judge in the United States, Leonie Brinkema, ruled that Google "intentionally acquired and maintained monopoly power" in two segments of the online advertising market, and illegally bundled these two aspects by requiring websites that wished to fully access its advertising platform to also use its advertising servers.
But Google has also won a case involving AI Overviews. In September, U.S. District Judge Amit Mehta dismissed the lawsuit filed by Penske Media against Google for using its content to generate AI Overviews, ruling that Penske had not reasonably proven that Search and AI Overviews were two separate products.
Teachout indicates that the situation varies from school to school, as there is clear independent market demand evidence for the separation of "school search from AI".
Whether the court will accept such cases, or whether it will agree with the views of Teachout, remains unknown at this time. Google's new policy will take effect at the beginning of next year. Before that, each school district must decide whether it is worth accepting the subsequent AI in order to retain Google Search.












